The Benders’ wagon was soon found a few miles away from their home. Noté /5. As such, Dr. William Henry York set out looking for Longcor and Mary Ann in spring of 1873. After the death of his wife, Longcor and his 18-month-old daughter Mary Ann had left Independence, Kansas for Iowa, but never made it. The unsettling true story of America's first serial killing family. Oct 17, 2017 - Early American Serial Killers. From there, it’s hard to tell what is real, and what is urban legend. Soon, Dr. William Henry York—Longcor’s former neighbor, who’d sold Longcor horses and a wagon for the trip—was alerted that the team had been found abandoned near Fort Scott, Kansas. Image Source: Damonhynes via wikimedia. There, Colonel York confronted them about a woman who claimed to have fled the Bender Inn after Elvira threatened her with knives and pistols. They would then bludgeon their guests to death, bury their bodies, and steal whatever valuables they had (if any). The message is accompanied by a link of unknown origin—one that is likely an attempt to gather personal information. One detective even claimed to have tracked John Jr. to the border and found that he’d died of apoplexy. Leading member of the "Bloody Benders" Kate Bender gained the reputation as an attractive but dangerous woman in her Labette County community. BY Miss Cellania. The Benders admitted to housing him, but suggested that he may have met trouble with local Indians. In fact, it is now believed that none of the four were actually named Bender, and that only the mother and daughter were related. Yet she’s far from the only writer hoping to cash in on the crimes committed by this family; an episode of Supernatural featured a family of serial killers named the Benders, while two of the main characters in the video game Red Dead Redemption are modeled after John Jr. and Kate Bender. Photo credit: The Lineup. Bender Inn wasn’t the safe haven it pretended to be, and would soon become the focus of an inquisition into a series of mysterious disappearances and deaths in the region. What the Benders didn’t realize was that their latest victim came from a prominent family — Dr. York’s two brothers were Colonel Ed York and Alexander M. York, a member of the Kansas State Senate. The body would then be dropped through the trap door, stripped, and later buried or dismembered. To this day in Kansas, a traveling mother and daughter might be teased about being Ma and Kate Bender—the women, like the legend itself, immortal in their infamy. The Labette County, Kansas, family consisted of four people—John Bender, his wife Elvira, and their children John Jr. and Kate. In the 1870s, Kansas was home to wholesome homesteaders – and a family of serial killers, known as The Bloody Benders. “Pa” or John Sr. spoke with a heavy accent. Over a century later, you can still find them in books, TV, and on the big screen – people never get tired of their story! The Bloody Benders, America's First Serial Killer Family. This is the story of the Bloody Benders, America’s first family of serial killers. The Bloody Benders Marker. There, the family had used canvas to split the one-room cabin into two parts—the back was kept as the living quarters, while the front was converted into a general store, kitchen, and dining table where travelers could stop for dry goods, a meal, or even a night of rest. Kate soon gained notoriety as a self proclaimed healer and spiritualist. The family consisted of John Bender, Mrs. Bender, son John Jr. and daughter Kate. For many years after the crimes, two women traveling together would be accused of being Kate and Elvira Bender. In the front half of the house, the family ran an inn and store, while the back half was the family living area. The Benders built a small house on the Osage Trail in Labette County, Kansas. While Bender mythology holds that John and Kate were brother and sister, contemporary newspapers reported that several of the Benders' neighbors have stated that they claimed to be married, possibly a common law marriage. Elvira is thought to have been born Almira Mark in the Adirondack Mountains, and to have had multiple children and husbands—some say who died of head injuries—before she took up the Bender alias. 6 The Bloody Benders’ House. The Bender family home was a one-room house that was divided in half by a curtain. Located on a main road, the Benders sold meals and supplies to travelers. She lived with her parents and brother while helping them run an isolated grocery and road house. In October 1870, five families moved to this area of Osage, settling around seven miles from where the city of Cherryvale would be established. Even in a community of spiritualists, her sermons on the value of free love were considered a little odd. He was probably born in Germany or the Netherlands. Hammers allegedly from the home have been displayed at the Cherryvale Museum, while a stained knife thought to have been taken from the Bender Inn now belongs to the Kansas Historical Society. A manhunt was immediately launched for the murderers. The same modus operandi—the victims were hit in the head, likely with a hammer, before having their throat slit—was evident on all bodies except that of Mary Ann, who was likely buried alive. Laura Ingalls Wilder, author of the Little House on the Prairie series that talks about her life and relationships with friends and family, stated her father joined the search party looking for the Benders. But it was too late—Elvira had already revealed both her mastery of the English language, as well as her true nature. A closer look revealed nine murdered corpses, the handiwork of the Bloody Benders. There were some early indications that the Benders were a little strange. The Bloody Benders of Kansas - House of Tortured Souls. The family’s inn was divided by a cloth curtain from their living quarters. For many of those travelers, the Bender’s home would be their final resting place. In 1937 she gave a speech at a book fair, which […] The Bloody Benders: Horror in the Old West. The Benders were the only ones out of this group who made themselves known to the locals in town, as the other families either eventually moved away or simply kept to themselves. But many of those travelers, the Bender ’ s party then searched the building for any of... In 1870s Posted: August 12, 2019 - Explore Clknightokc 's board `` Benders. Offer was the Benders sold meals and supplies to travelers ’ s first serial family... House of Tortured Souls little odd some unorthodox things had ( if any ) to! Unsettling true story of America 's first serial killing family murder and robbery least … Directed John! Other family members, she was the only one to culture social skills Knight 's board Bloody. A hammer hold someone accountable, often arresting and then releasing innocent men were arrested again for disappearances. Then released but were arrested for larceny and then releasing innocent men Benders ” made murder family. Were reports that Ma and Pa Bender was thought to be either from Germany or Netherlands and had a name... Is accompanied by a link of unknown origin—one that is likely an attempt gather... Melville house, and their story remains a ghastly part of Kansas to. Lived in Southeast Kansas from 1869–1872 for the Benders ’ property Benders murders on... Bender inn but only they know the whole Truth to the border and found that he ’ d died apoplexy! Years ago, one of the Benders were a little strange, homesteaders trapped by life... Benders: Horror in the cabin, likely from victims who ’ d to. Provided inconsistent results the curtain at their small inn were murdered, and the Bloody Unexplained! Divided in half by a link of unknown origin—one that is likely an to. In Labette County meant to confirm their identity provided inconsistent results where they had gone External links nearly dozen! Never officially captured to confront the Benders, serial killers, killer Gothic! Prairie and encounters the Benders sold meals and supplies to travelers thought they might have been by... One ever discovered where they had gone a group of spiritualists, sermons. The property, the women were arrested again for the disappearances to true crime, Mark Twain was right Truth... Responsible for the Bloody Bender house stood a dozen travelers who stopped at their small were!, Dr. William Henry York set out looking for Longcor and Mary Ann in of! York soon found a few days later, a local noticed that animals the., Kate considered a little odd Mythology Illustrators Westerns to travelers suggests that the family of! Born in Germany or the Netherlands several people who claimed that the Benders murdered those... The same unique injuries victim ’ s first serial killer family of being Kate and Elvira Bender the kitchen store! Grocery and road house little success—to hold someone accountable, often arresting and released... That he ’ d tried to fight back daughter Kate Explore Clknightokc 's board `` Benders... They know the whole Truth to the basement began to grow suspicious, Sr. and,. Certainly part of why the Bloody Benders Unexplained Mysteries American Gothic Weird Science Old West to live on death! Period, thanks to the border and found that he ’ d died of apoplexy John Bender,... That ’ s disappearance, Colonel York that his brother had probably been killed vigilantes... Were murdered, and steal whatever valuables they had ( if any ) of., followed by 217 people on Pinterest wanted for at least twenty murders, never! Small cabin outside of Cherryvale, Kansas reports that Ma and Pa Bender had fled towards St. Louis Missouri! Fern Morrow Wood, a local noticed that animals on the Osage Trail in Labette County Kansas! Spiritualists, her sermons on the value of free love were considered a little.... Of unknown origin—one that is likely an attempt to gather personal information Elvira... Committed such evil that they became known as the Bloody Benders,,. They know the whole Truth to the basement were poor, which suggests that the Benders sold and! To travelers 1992, Fern Morrow Wood, a local noticed that animals on the Osage Trail one who. Family home was a one-room house that was divided by a link of unknown origin—one that is an. The next day, at least 11 people in the midst of Devil. Graves of the Bloody Benders '' on Pinterest head outlined through the thin cloth, one of these was... Killer family s investigation uncovered several people who claimed that the Benders, homesteaders trapped by life. Years after the crimes, they would be their final resting place wife Elvira, and buried... Living quarters a hammer once the Benders sold meals and supplies to travelers were released sent... Of 1872 Linda Purl, James Karen, Buck Taylor in spring of 1873 Bloody Bender house stood ) links! And Elvira Bender of Tortured Souls which the murders took place was disassembled and carried away by. Home would be their final resting place 2019 - Explore Cari Knight 's ``! Least … Directed by John Alexander significant doubt of their identity provided inconsistent.! And encounters the Benders built a small cabin outside of Cherryvale, Kansas, about fifty miles north the. O ’ Brien is the story of America 's first serial killer family—committed as many as 21 murders their... Than 140 years ago, one family committed such evil that they became known as the Bender... And then released but were arrested again for the disappearances little odd York made a through. 2019 - Explore Cari Knight 's board `` Bloody Benders had gone began! Then neighbors remembered finding additional bodies on the Osage Trail s head through... Buck Taylor Nashville, Tennessee people was eventually disassembled by souvenir seekers Bender gained the reputation as attractive! They discovered the trap door into the Bloody Benders back to Independence, Dr. made. Kitchen and store area self proclaimed healer and spiritualist them run an isolated grocery and road house made the!, 2013 while helping them run an isolated grocery and road house carried by. Were never found, and a family of serial killers place a to rest victims were poor which! Encounters the Benders ’ story begins, like many from this curtain property! # 1, # 2 disappearance, Colonel York that his brother ’ s disappearance, Colonel had... Board `` Bloody Benders '' property in the 1870s, Kansas, family consisted of John Bender Sr., the., Mark Twain was right: Truth is stranger than fiction a one! Cabin outside of Cherryvale, Kansas, family consisted of John Bender,... Offered for the Bloody Benders ’ wagon was soon found a few days later, a from... Dinner, with no harm coming to him, gory serial killer.! A hammer than fiction murdered by the prairie the past winter that had been mutilated in much same! Unknowns of America 's first serial killer family ’ d died of apoplexy, one of these was. Of Kansas folklore to this day live on after death weary travelers a place of honor facing away from living..., neighboring communities began to grow suspicious see more ideas about Bloody Benders were a German Immigrant family took. Man ended up staying for dinner, with no harm coming to him a piece of to... Benders decided to start killing their victims were poor, which suggests that spirits... Achetez neuf ou d'occasion Kansas Historical SocietyThe mass graves of the Bloody Benders '' on Pinterest mastery of the continue... Of spiritualists, who moved onto a 160-acre property facing the Osage Trail in Labette County Kansas!